Hospitalization & mental health providers · Opinion · Uncategorized

If someone offers you 5 million dollars… save mental health

Someone once offered me five million dollars to pursue an idea.

The problem

Let me start in the beginning.  If you’ve ever worked or been a patient in a psychiatric hospital, you know about the problem:  there’s no middle ground between the tight routine & support of being hospitalized and the toss-you-out-into-the-world discharge plan that follows.  In simpler terms, when leaving a psychiatric hospital, people go from 24-hour structure and nursing care to… well, the real world.  And they don’t do well.

Patients run out of medication.  Their families aren’t always supportive.  Community resources are scarce.  Supportive housing even scarcer.  And America is a lonely place; few people, especially those with mental illness, have enough support.  Within months, or days, the seriously mentally ill person has fallen through the cracks, gone into crisis, and returned to the hospital.

This discharge-rehospitalization cycle happens over and over.  In psychiatry we call this the “revolving door” phenomena.  It’s tragic, and it’s expensive.  Many psychiatrically ill patients depend on Medicaid for their health care.  The public spends millions of dollars each year paying for these emergency room visits and hospitalizations.

Most countries have solved this issue by establishing a middle step between hospitalization and community: the rehabilitative or residential psychiatric hospital.  Most countries, that is, except the United States.

Take Spain, for example.

In late 2004 one chilly morning I stepped through the doors of an old, beautifully architected, two-story building sitting against the backdrop of a small garden and busy city street (too much detail, I know, but I want you to get a clear image of the place).  This was a rehabilitative psychiatric hospital in Asturias, Spain.

Behind unlocked doors I found a long hallway filled with patients cleaning out their rooms.  Hired caregivers were directing them through the process, rapidly braiding one patient’s hair, patting another fellow on the back, while teasing a third about the laundry she’d hidden under her bed.  Apparently they were late for their first class: dance.

The caregivers directed me to the gym.  Here I found a medley of couples prancing around to upbeat music.  Staff and patients danced together, a good hundred patients at least. I rested back in a corner until the dance was over (hoping nobody would ask me to prance), and the treatment team stepped over to introduce themselves: a head psychologist, couple of social workers, and a large group of nurses and caregivers.

“Many patients come here after they’re discharged from the hospital,” they explained.  “Especially those who aren’t ready to live out there.  They usually stay at this place a year.  Here they learn how to function in the community… socialize properly, use public transportation, transition over to a group home or their own apartment, start a job, go back to school (if they’re up to it), learn to drive… and make friends.  After they leave, they’re welcome to return for some of the groups, and they’re encouraged to keep in touch with one another.  Friendship is important.”

As an American psychiatrist, I was… what?  Taken aback?  Aghast, elated, confused?  Staff dancing with patients?  Encouraging people to maintain friendship after discharge?  Open doors, open ticket to return whenever they want?  And how was this affordable?  Who paid for this?  The details seemed fishy.

Later that day I buried myself in a search engine.  Research revealed the truth: rehabilitative or residential psychiatric programs reduce emergency room and hospital usage.  It saves money.  And having an intermediate level of care is better for patients.  They reintegrate back into the community at a healthier pace.

We’re missing something essential in American psychiatry.  Outside the VA system, this level of care doesn’t exist.  No one will pay for it.  The irony is we’d save money if only we were willing to take that first step.

Five million dollars

So we’re back to that five million dollars.

It would have been a philanthropic venture, the establishment of a civilian psychiatric residential hospital in the United States, and boy I’d researched the topic thoroughly.  I had twenty pages of notes back then.  Here are the highlights.

(1) Admission criteria.  Patients will need close screening for admission.  Admission would be reserved for the severely mentally ill (SMI) population, those with Schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, bipolar, and depression.  People with severe anxiety would be considered.  This setting is inappropriate for individuals with borderline personality disorder.  Care should be taken when accepting clients with substance use disorders, complicated medical issues, etc.

(2) Individualized care.  Meet the patient where they’re at.  Individualize care and long-term plan.  Does the person need a group home with 24-hour supervision or their own apartment with a job and nighttime classes in calculus?  Is the family supportive and healthy enough to be involved?

(3) Useful, achievement-oriented classes.  Classes should set the patient up for success.  They should also be useful.  Start at one level lower than the patient’s current functioning and advance as possible.  Classes can include:

  • social skills
  • money management (making change, maintaining a budget)
  • basic reading and writing
  • modern topic discussion
  • deciphering a map or GPS
  • using a cell phone/computer
  • learning job skills
  • looking for work and filling out applications
  • maintaining a job
  • gathering college-preparation skills
  • seeking out appropriate housing

(4) Fun classes.  There must be fun and soulful classes, like dancing, art, creativity, gardening, hiking, visiting the zoo, learning how to play an instrument, etc

(5) Community reintegration.  As the patient progresses, they should transition into the community and gain more independence, like going for walks, spending time at a potential group home, going to classes, working during the day, and saving up for and choosing a car

(6) Friendship and inclusion. We must encourage patients to make friends with other patients and, after discharge, return and participate in groups.  We need to have room to make this happen.  This idea — friendship between patients — will make many providers cringe, but encouraging that connection is actually the norm in many countries.

(7) Failure to graduate.   Plans must be made for management of people who don’t graduate from the program; avoid becoming a nursing home or boarding house.  Rehabilitation is the key.

(8) Contingency plans. Plans must be made for handling psychiatric crises, agitation and aggression, medication management (a psychiatrist could visit weekly or biweekly), medical emergencies, injury, death, accusations of abuse, and other potential incidents.

(9) Unanswered questions.  There’s a lot we don’t know. Who would finance this, and how much money is needed to get it started/keep it going?  What parts of patient life must they finance themselves?  What kind of insurance would the facility need?  How would the facility deal with HIPAA when the patients have cell phones and can take pictures of one another?

In the end, I turned down the five million dollars.  I knew it wasn’t enough money, but more than that, I knew from the beginning it wasn’t my calling.   I’m no good at administration.

But if there’s anyone out there who’s inspired enough to take this idea and run, please do.  Thousands of people will thank you.  Or tens of thousands.


3 thoughts on “If someone offers you 5 million dollars… save mental health

  1. Medicaid has a fairly new program called Specialized Recovery Services. I’m not sure if it’s nationwide or just in my state. But it’s been over a year since I applied , and even though I finally got the assessment , there is still no word on whether I qualify. In theory it’s a step forward in offering care, but what good is it when the timeline is so dragged out? You are so right about being thrown out into the real world after inpatient admissions. I think it should be similar to what many addiction treatment centers do, where after inpatient you are expected to participate in a rigorous full-time outpatient program to maintain some routine and get further care.


    1. Hi s.e. taylor:

      I’m glad to hear you finally got assessed for this program, but wow it’s taking a long time! A whole year! Unless a person stays in the hospital the whole time waiting for the service to kick in, where do they stay? What do they do? It seems to defeat the purpose.

      Yes, absolutely, there aught to be psychiatric treatment centers comparable to addiction residential settings. I’d even be happy if there were more group homes and transitional housing in the community. We need more services, no? More vocational rehab/ job training, reading and writing classes, plus more stuff that feeds the soul, like art therapy and tai chi.

      Anyway, keep your head up, no matter where you are, and have faith in the future. Good luck with the Specialized Recovery Services. Until next time!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s