How to Motivate SUD Clients in Group Therapy
For Drug & Alcohol Counselors
by Kim Rosenthal, MD
Imagine your professional life is a fairy tale. You’re a shining example of humanity, touched by the gods, and you levitate at the front of the room as your clients step into view and watch you with gentle admiration. Already you’ve impressed them. They’re taken aback by your levitation, eager to hear your every word, and with a whirl of magic you carry them into the journey of a lifetime: Recovery! What excitement! What passion! Together therapist and clients stomp out drug addiction. Enter world peace and universal harmony. Hunger disappears forever.
It doesn’t happen that way, does it? SUD clients are rarely enthusiastic about treatment. They’re often distracted, tired, or interested in other things, all symptoms of early recovery. What do they need? How do you grab clients’ interest and keep it? We’re not talking about the grand task of moving a client from pre-contemplative to sustained recovery. Certainly, that’s the goal and beyond, but at this point we’re focused on the little things, about spicing up groups now. Apart from levitation and magic, what can you do to inspire your clients today?
While there’s no solution that works for everyone, there are things you can do. Here are nine tips for grabbing clients’ interest and keeping it.
TIP ONE: Motivational Interviewing
Everyone knows motivation is about motivational interviewing, right? That’s motivation to change, to advance along the road to recovery. There’s a personable, playful, and irreverent approach behind motivational interviewing. It doesn’t assume. It doesn’t judge. It doesn’t discipline. It doesn’t talk down to others. It asks questions and makes room for conversation. Yeah, use that approach. It’s the difference between “Thou shalt not steal thy sister’s Oxycontin because it is a sin” and “Hell, man, was it a good idea to steal those pills, really? But a little part of you regrets it?” This wouldn’t be a motivational article if we didn’t mention motivational interviewing. Done.
TIP TWO: Use Body Language
Words are never enough. Careful use of body language is a great tool for your arsenal. I learned this when working with my deaf patients: There’s more to humans than verbal information. Visually, you can vary your presentation in a dozen of ways. There’s eye contact. There’s motion vs. lack of motion. There’s slow vs fast, broad vs. small, serious vs grinning, tired vs alive. Our patients are trained geniuses when it comes to reading out body language, and it shows.
Talk with your body. Broaden your movements. Pause, cross your arms, and wink at someone. Flail your arms, saying “Hey back there, put away that phone!” Put your hand under your chin, allow a moment of thoughtful silence, then shrug meaningfully, saying “Does everyone agree?” Clap your hands and offer recognition, “Bravo! You’re right!” If you’re bold, put your head down on the table when faced with contradiction, say “I’m soooo confused… help me make sense out of that!” Then offer your client a smile. Do so meaningfully, and keep the conversation going. My old favorite is to talk softly and minimize body language when the crowd is out of control; they’ll hush and lean in to hear what they’re missing.
TIP THREE: Ask Questions
Most of us do this, but it’s worth mentioning: Ask questions! Clients tend to engage more when asked to engage. For example, rather than lecturing on ways to deal with problems, we pull people into conversation by asking open-ended questions: “What kinds of problems are you facing? How do you deal with them?” Ask about things that pertain to the client, easy enough to get them involved, hard enough to challenge them. Want extra credit? Keep the questions interesting. “Do you believe in a geographical cure? What if I went to Antarctica and never saw drugs again? Would I be cured?” “What’s the difference between sobriety and recovery? “If there were a pill that fixed addiction, would you take it? If one pill helped, would it be better to take 2 or 3?”
TIP FOUR: Use Scenarios
Scenarios are superb ways to introduce topics. “Imagine you’re alone on a Saturday night, bored witless, and here comes a craving… What do you do?”
One of my favorite approaches is to present a scenario with a question, then offer a few solutions and have clients decide which solution works. For example, “You’re in Africa on a safari, and an angry elephant is rushing towards you! What’s the best coping skill to use in this situation?” Solution #1, ““You relax your shoulders and take ten deep breaths.” Solution #2, “You avoid the elephant. You run, jump into your car, and rush away as fast as you can.” Obviously, Solution #2 is right. Why? What’s the point? “Relaxing and breathing is a superb coping skill,” I tell clients, “but not in every situation. It won’t fix everything. You need to have other skills. In fact, the more coping skills you have, the better.”
TIP FIVE: Use Visual Aids
We recognize that drugs mess with the brain. People in early recovery struggle with concentration, verbal abilities, memory, motivation, and mood. It takes time to heal. This means clients grasp and relate to information better if it’s presented in multiple ways. Thus, we augment verbal information with visual input. How? Use calendars to create schedules, use cartoons to offset the dry stuff, use videos to jumpstart discussion, use colorful objects to anchor thoughts in place on the board. Don’t forget books, clipart, field trips, and technology. Think outside the box and add rhythm and music.
Engage clients by asking them questions about the visual aid. For example, to help them better understand emotion, show them photos or artwork of people in different emotional states. Choose pictures with context: Someone getting arrested, a man being ignored by a group, a woman who’s upset at her computer, someone who just won the lottery. Next, ask lots of questions.
- How is each person in the picture feeling?
- What kinds of things caused them to feel this way?
- Is it okay to feel this way? Have you ever felt this way?
- What should they do next? What shouldn’t they do?
- How can they best deal with the emotion?
To keep things interesting, include unusual or funny pictures like the Cookie Monster from Sesame Street. “What is he feeling? What happens next?” Collect hundreds of images, and use them!
TIP SIX: Hand clients a pen.
There’s something about recording recovery on paper that solidifies it, making it real. The movement of the hand, the recorded self-reflection, the visual product, the additional source of information, it’s all vital to helping clients retain information. Writing also acts as an anchor, a proverbial cord that ties recovery into their lives. Want to remember relapse prevention info when it’s most needed? Try writing it out a hundred times before it’s actually needed.
Clients should be encouraged to take notes in class. They should write relapse prevention plans, crisis plans, ways to deal with triggers, and reasons they want to quit — often, repeatedly, until it’s imbedded in the very frame of their being.
They should also be encouraged to journal, create poetry, even write stories about recovery. Making time for these activities during group time can promote treatment retention.
TIP SEVEN: Encourage artwork.
Collage, drawing, and other creative tasks are an excellent way to help clients approach aspects of their lives in a safe, nonverbal way. For example, encourage clients to draw a “picture of recovery.” They should color and shade, then label what is what in their drawing. After the fact, they can discuss their findings:
- Why did they draw what they did?
- What stage of recovery did they draw? How does it compare to their reality?
- What surprised them about the image?
- Are there good and bad parts? If the image isn’t a positive one, why not? Is this normal?
Art therapy is especially good for processing painful parts of one’s experience, where words can feel too vulnerable.
TIP EIGHT: Give Them a Quiz.
Combined with serious information, interesting and humored quizzes can promote motivation. Start groups out with a simple True/False Quiz. True or False: (1) Withdrawing from alcohol can be deadly (True). (2) Alcohol withdrawal symptoms include shakiness, sweats, problems sleeping, seizures, confusion, and long sprouts of hair growing out of your ears (True except for the ear hair). (3) It’s illegal to give alcohol to a moose in Alaska (True). (4) Some cigarettes made in China contain insect parts and human feces (True). Keep clients guessing and they’ll learn as much as they laugh. (You’ll find various free, fun quizzes at https://kimrosenthalmd.com/outside-the-box-recovery-free-material.).
TIP NINE: Know When to Switch Gears
This is an old trick. Teachers use it all the time. If you look up to find glazed over stares — it’s time to try something different. It isn’t you. It’s the recovering brain. You might be tempted to end the session early, but there is a different option: Keep an arsenal of extra activities at the ready! Not sure where to find your arsenal? Ask your colleagues, gather recovery workbooks, and search online. Consider alternating between hands-on and technology, like music, smartscreens, apps, and useful social media. (You can also check out Amazon and my website for loads of stuff.)
CONCLUSION
You don’t need to levitate or wax on the magical to keep clients motivated (though it helps!). Just remember to engage them with motivational interviewing, ask questions, use nonverbal material to supplement your words, promote creativity and the occasional laugh, use scenarios, hand out pens, vary activities to overcome audience concentration problems, and maintain an arsenal of extra activities to keep things interesting. This doesn’t replace mainstream treatment. It enhances it.
Kim Rosenthal, MD
Psychiatrist
REFERENCES
Much of these pointers are taken from my teaching years (I taught middle and high school prior to becoming a physician) as well as from the considerable wealth of literature supporting the use of humor, conversational interviewing, nonverbal interventions, alternative approaches including technology, and creativity to promote the care of MH and SUD clients.
- Canha B. Using Humor in Treatment of Substance Use Disorders: Worthy of Further Investigation. Open Nurs J. 2016 Apr 30;10:37-44.
- Enhancing Motivation for Change in Substance Use Disorder Treatment: Updated 2019 [Internet]. Rockville (MD): Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (US); 2019. (Treatment Improvement Protocol (TIP) Series, No. 35.) Chapter 8—Integrating Motivational Approaches in SUD Treatment Settings. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Sarink FSM, García-Montes JM. Humor interventions in psychotherapy and their effect on levels of depression and anxiety in adult clients, a systematic review. Front Psychiatry. 2023 Jan 4;13:1049476.
- Williamson B. The importance of Body Language in Teaching. Everfi.com (Date not available). https://everfi.com/blog/k-12
About me.
My name is Kim Rosenthal, MD. I’m a board-certified psychiatrist with experience working in detox, rehab, partial hospital, inpatient, ACT teams, and with our veterans. Although I treat all psychiatric conditions, SUD clients carry a special place in my heart. I started the Outside-the-Box Recovery movement to promote a zest for sober living by way of creative, humored, and clinically-relevant worksheets for counselors to use with people in early recovery. To find out more and download tons of recovery material, check out the “free” section of this website. You’ll also find several, really cool workbooks on Amazon! Treatment modalities include cognitive behavioral therapy, motivational interviewing, relapse prevention, mindfulness, narrative therapy, coping skills, and creativity therapy.


Leave a Reply